Acrylic Mirror Failures Learning Opportunities

The acrylic mirror samples arrived. I got 3 mirrors about the size of a credit card, but thicker, like a piece of glass.

OBJECTIVE: Create a "trough mirror" that focuses onto a line.

KEY FACT #1: Acrylic mirror softens and bends at around 230-250°F.

KEY FACT #2: A parabola is a mathematically perfect focusing shape, but (a small section of) a circle is plenty fine for my needs.

FIRST ATTEMPT:

I got a big, glass jar with smooth sides. I put it lying down inside the oven. I balanced the mirror on top, shiny side pointing down (and with the protective plastic sheet still on it). I had to tape the mirror in place.

Starting at around 215°F, I slowly heated the oven up until the mirror ends started drooping. After probably an hour of watching it slooooooowly bend, I just reached in with an oven mitt and press-formed it to the glass.

RESULT: Meh. The shape is great and the focusing is accurate but the mirror got all foggy. It looks more like polished metal now. Also the spots where the tape was touching are distorted.

SECOND ATTEMPT:

My theory was that I should have the mirror pointing up, which might make the cloudiness go away and would make using tape unnecessary.

This time I used a regular soup pan tipped on its side. I put the mirror inside so it could form to the inside curve of the pan. Left the protective plastic on. Set the oven to 250°F (that's what I had worked up to from the first attempt) and waited. And waited. And waited.

Once again, I eventually just reached in and press formed it. When I removed the sheet....still cloudy.

THIRD ATTEMPT:

I watched the video again. Oh, I'm supposed to remove the protective plastic. Replay the second attempt, but this time remove the thing first.

After waiting the requisite Long Time, I could see the mirror was already foggy even before I press forming it. Aha! Not the plastic or the form!

WHAT'S PROBABLY GOING ON:

I have small samples, so gravity isn't enough to bend them until they are very soft from being in the oven for 45 minutes or more. In that amount of time, some chemical degradation (or something) is causing the cloudiness. If I rig up some way to put a weight on top of the sample, maybe I could speed that up. Or I could just reach in there earlier and do it by hand.

But now I'm out of samples. I can bend and rebend the cloudy ones just to test out some weighting system and/or get my timing right. But I'll only be able to check if the cloudiness disappears if I buy more mirror. Which I can do, but I hate the shipping charges. Ah well.

Miscellaneous

1. I had a long, long thing here about how following my plan was so easy, but it kept reading like Tighter Buns in 30 Days While Eating Pizza, so let's leave it at this: Down by almost 27 pounds.
2. Way back when, I did some solar experiments. I said I'd come back to that. I'm still working on that. The problem is, the design I came up with is kind of crappy.

   What I want is a parabolic trough mirror focused on a central pipe. I've tried using mylar sheets on various surfaces before, but it didn't come out too well. This time I tried strips of mirror laid in a wooden parabolic form. I haven't tested it yet, but it doesn't look too convincing on the workbench. Lots of gaps, not much total area, not well focused, etc. (No picture, because seriously.)

   While I was wondering what to do about all this, I came across this video. The guy comes across as a little infomercially, but his ideas look pretty good. In particular, I didn't know you could "drape form" plexiglass (aka "acrylic") mirror. That changes everything! Almost zero work and much higher efficiency.

3. Which brings me to the third misc item. WhereTF do you find acrylic mirror at a reasonable price? I've found it as low as $4.50/sqft, but you have to buy at least $50, not to mention shipping. Plenty of ebayers, but the price with shipping never comes out lower than ~$12/sqft and you have to buy several sqft to get that. Lowe's can special order it, but you have to buy 5 48"x96" sheets and it's still $8/sqft. McMaster-Carr, despite their awesome website, doesn't reveal shipping information even if you ask a live human being, which, HELLO.

   This kind of mirror is used in a lot of children's products because it's shatterproof, so I've considered repurposing a baby mirror, but the cost is still pretty high there due to packaging, frames, etc. I've even wandered around Home Depot and Lowe's to see if I could find a bathroom/decorative/whatever acrylic mirror on some other product. The sole success was a really, really crappy medicine cabinet with attached acrylic mirror. The whole unit was $12 and the mirror was 2 sqft.

   I would just go with that, but the fact that it's attached to something else only proves that I should be able to get the mirror alone for cheaper. Also, I hate to buy something specifically so I can throw it away. In the mean time, I ordered a set of these to experiment with. With the shipping, even amortized over several other items in my order, the price per sqft comes out at lalalaicanthearyou.